GIP-18: Should GnosisDAO invest at TickDAO?

GIP-18: Should GnosisDAO invest at TickDAO?

  • Let’s do this!
  • Make no changes

0 voters

GIP: 18
title: TickDAO Investment
author: Kelvin Santos <kelvin@tickspread.com>
status: phase-2
type: Funding
created: 2021-12-08

Simple Summary

Tick is a hybrid cryptocurrency exchange powered by an off-chain, auction-based
order matching system. Here is a link to our alpha version: https://tickspread.com/

Context

After produtive discussions with @fleupold, originating from Ethereum Research, he introduced me to the Gnosis founding team (@mkoeppelmann, @ernst, @StefanGeorge), and we jointly agreed that having Gnosis as an investor at Tick would be mutually beneficial.

Based on that, we negotiated a deal in which Gnosis would invest $500,000 worth of ETH at a 20MM post-money valuation, followed by another $500,000 from angel investors. We are thrilled to have such strategic investors and we are looking forward to see this deal happening though GnosisDAO.

Here is a document with an introduction on what we are doing and details of the proposal.

Specification

  • GnosisDAO will invest $500,000 worth of ETH to purchase 12,500,000 TICK out of a current
    supply of 500,000,000.
  • A group of angel investors will invest $500,000 to buy another 12,500,000 TICK on the
    same conditions.
  • Company funds will be stored at TickDAO, a 3-out-of-4 Gnosis Safe (tickdao.eth).
  • The signers consist of two team members, one major investor, and GnosisDAO.
  • TickDAO holds the minter role for TICK tokens.
  • All revenues, including but not limited to trading fees generated by the protocol, will
    flow back to TickDAO.
  • The team will periodically request funds for its operations.
  • TickDAO shall approve requests done in good faith and in accordance the most recent
    business plan, as disclosed to the signers.
  • TickDAO shall approve of a plan to yield the power from the Gnosis Safe to a futarchy
    mechanism.
  • While operating in a custodial manner:
    • User assets will be held in a separate 3-out-of-4 Gnosis Safe (tick.eth).
    • The company will accept deposits and withdrawals through xDai/Gnosis Chain.
  • Once operating in a non-custodial manner:
    • User assets will be held in settlement contracts in different chains/rollups, including
      one to be deployed at xDai/Gnosis Chain.

Links

6 Likes

I support this proposal. I met Kelvin and agree with his analysis on ethreasearch (link for reference) regarding batch auctions being a superior trading mechanism in the face of HFT and MEV particularly on blockchains.

TickSpread is quite different from CowSwap in that it focuses on 2 sided orderbooks (no ringtrades) and works on much faster batch times (1 second vs. lower bound 15s ethereum block time for CowSwap). The settling is done by a single party (no “solver” competition). In that sense I think the protocol is much simpler than CowSwap and may allow for faster iteration and complementary insights into the consequences of using batch auctions for DEX trading.

Therefore I think having his team as part of the Gnosis ecosystem would be a strong addition.

6 Likes

We had a couple of calls with Kelvin and I can confirm Kelvin is a very vision-driven founder with a clear roadmap in mind. Given that GIP-16 will be approved by STAKE and GNO holders, it is important to point out that TickSpread will be deployed and operated (not necessarily exclusively) on Gnosis Chain. TickSpread can be a very important dApp to foster the adoption of the Gnosis Chain.

4 Likes

I support this proposal. I have spoken with Kelvin on it extensively and am heartened by his team’s commitment to building a high frequency batch auction matching engine AND progressively decentralizing it. Kevin’s values line up with Gnosis core beliefs perfectly. Clearly, Tick are still at the beginning but have an MVP and a plan :muscle:. Together with their commitment to Gnosis chain, this to me is a strong investment case.

3 Likes

The proposal has been moved to phase-2 and a poll is now open (thanks @auryn_macmillan). Thank you all for the support.

Please vote!

1 Like

After discussing with @mkoeppelmann, we agreed to use the last spot price from Chainlink to convert the proposal from USD equivalent to ETH, so that we can proceed to phase-3 voting. Current conversion rate of $4,142.21 according to

image

According to that the proposal is for GnosisDAO to invest 120.7085 ETH into TickDAO and receive 12,500,000 TICK tokens in return.

2 Likes

The snapshot vote is now open!

Voting will continue for seven days, closing on Dec 31st, 3pm UTC.

3 Likes

Dear TickDAO team,

As stated in this forum post we are introducing new measures to ensure transparency and accountability around GIPs funded by the GnosisDAO.

Accordingly, we are asking the teams who authored GIPs and received funding to provide updates about their work. Please use this template as a guideline. Additionally we have some GIP specific questions for you.

In your proposal you mentioned the following advantages over other protocols:

  • This effectively creates a built-in liquidity aggregator, allowing us to have deeper liquidity than any other exchange, centralized or not, subject only to our capital availability.

  • Leveraging better mechanisms, we completely nullify this obstacle to be in a uniquely strong position among challengers. With lower transaction costs, we can generate more value for our users, allowing more efficient portfolio rebalancing, dynamic hedging, and short-term speculation. By providing deep liquidity in a non-custodial setting, we can help accelerate the migration of trading volume to DeFi.

  • We are initially focusing on short-term, high leverage custodial futures trading. This allows us to get early user feedback from a target market that we consider very valuable in the long run, at the same time validating our market mechanism. Since transaction costs are crucial for them, we will have a strong competitive advantage in this niche.

  • At the same time, we are working to release a non-custodial spot market. We will protect users from frontrunning, reduce gas fees dramatically compared to Uniswap, and offer an orderbook that can be deep as (or even deeper than!) than that of centralized exchanges such as Binance or FTX.

From the first experience of your beta testers, please comment on whether your assumptions were met or not.

The community is invited to ask questions about the status of your project that should be addressed. Please make sure to monitor your post and respond to questions from the community.

We are looking forward to learning about the progress of your project. Moving forward we would appreciate it if you could give updates on a regular basis.

2 Likes

Report to GnosisDAO members

This report is derived from a report sent to all TickDAO investors on February 20th. These reports were previously sent only to Gnosis executives on behalf of GnosisDAO, but on their request, we’ll now make quarterly reports available to the wider GnosisDAO community.

REBRANDING

TickSpread is now called quiver.trade.

We did a relaunch late last year, redesigning the entire website, and created a waitlist that required users to input their email and Discord profiles, as well as share us on Twitter.

This helped us gain initial awareness on Twitter and get a critical mass of active users on our Discord server.

TRACTION

Previously, our goal was to prove that we could obtain minimal traction. We needed a significant set of real reference customers to make data-based product improvement possible.

We have succeeded at that! Over 10,000 people performed the necessary steps and signed up for our waitlist. Out of those, more than 2,000 created accounts, and over 250 unique accounts made real money deposits in January.

Some more data for January:

Total volume: 34.8 million USD (~15x growth in 6 months)

Fee Revenue: $ 1,200.54

Total Revenue: $ 1,777.75 (includes PnL from market making bots)

Total deposits: $ 18,560.81

Total withdrawals: $ 11,505.85

Daily unique traders: ~25

We currently have about 5 daily traders making over 30 complete trades in a day.

WHAT WE LEARNED

After testing multiple growth strategies, we learned two very important lessons:

  • The perception of scarcity is really important to drive user acquisition in crypto. The strategy that worked the best was to put up a waitlist that required several specific actions (making a tweet, connecting Discord, sharing crypto address) to join. Besides helping us stabilize user influx and creating a viral-like effect, it also made users somewhat psychologically invested in joining the app, which really improved all our metrics (intake, engagement, and retention).
  • Crypto users also rely heavily on social cues as indication of product reliability. Recommendation from reputable influencers in particular (as opposed to paid ads) are a great driver, as that kind of endorsement is much harder for potential low-quality products to obtain.

PROGRESS

Until Q4 2022, Quiver was yet to demonstrate product-market fit and prove there really was a segment of users to be served with lower fees.

I think our numbers this year is good evidence that this segment does indeed exist. While we transacted a substantial volume, the average trade on Quiver is quite small on a percentage basis, meaning it wouldn’t be viable at other exchanges, where the execution costs are higher. This makes us confident that we are really making the pie bigger, rather than (re)splitting it.

On the product and operations side, we iterated on sign-up/deposit flows to make them more intuitive, and we measured sevenfold improvements in funnel metrics with some relatively small changes. This means we are still quite early in the product improvement process.

We also finished our whitepaper.

NEXT STEPS

In light of the current growth, we expect to increase headcount (and burn rate) by hiring:

  • 3 new engineers/programmers (2 of them as replacements)

  • a Product Manager with significant experience in cryptocurrency trading

  • a COO with strong Silicon Valley experience (willing to give substantial equity as compensation)

Major features:

  • Automatic hot wallet
  • Stop Loss / Take Profit
  • Insurance fund (prevent auto-deleverage – trades being closed automatically)
  • Integration with Trade Terminals (used by many professional users)
  • Gamification and trading competitions
  • Listing several new crypto futures
  • Listing stocks/forex/commodities futures

FINANCE

Total Treasury: ~799k available

Current Burn Rate: ~25k/month (32 months runway)

Predicted Burn Rate: ~50k/month (16 months runway)

GROWTH STRATEGY

We believe we’ve found the core growth channel – getting trading influencers to endorse and continuously advertise our product with partnerships or referral programs. This can happen on Twitter, Youtube, Twitch, or personal blogs.

So far we’ve partnered with some very niche airdrop influencers, which did provide great results (majority of our current users) at a very low price (about ~$1000 in total cost), but probably won’t scale much.

Landing partnerships with key influencers that focus specifically on trading, particularly on technical analysis, may let us grow up dozens of times relatively quickly. To do so we need to build relationships to gain their trust, as well as deliver on basic features that are important for more serious traders.

Growth can be significant not only in the number of users, but also in the lifetime value of each user. We currently enforce a small $500 limit on user deposits, which we can lift once the system is reliable enough for more serious trading. More experienced users will certainly operate with much larger balances.

—

We are sure to have a lot of work to do over the next several months. It has been very rewarding to see the product we’ve been working on for years finally getting some steam, and I look forward to sharing even more exciting news in the near future. From now on I’ll keep you informed of updates at least quarterly (and potentially earlier if we have particularly relevant changes).

While we are not sharing the cap table publicly here on the forum, GnosisDAO continues to hold a 2.5% in our project. GnosisDAO members are free to reach out to receive a copy of the current cap table.

-Kelvin