Proposal: GIP-107
Vote: For
Reasoning: We originally raised various questions due to the limited information in the proposal. karpatkey’s very helpful response made clear that the arrangements have been carefully contemplated by Gnosis LTD and karpatkey, and legal advice has been taken. As legal entities are often a sensitive topic, with privilege protecting any legal advice, we are content to support those efforts despite the limited information. We are considering techniques for proposals to briefly notify of any sensitivities where limited information can be shared.
Proposal: GIP-109
Vote: For
Reasoning: We fully agree that proposal moderation is important, regardless of the number of current attacks. We also agreed with the comments from Refri that some limitations should be placed on moderators. Our response proposes a general principle that taken-down posts should be posted to the forum with a light-touch commitment to give reasons for the take down.
Proposal: GIP-111
Vote: For
Reasoning: As explained in our response comment, we recognise the importance of developing Ethereum in supporting Gnosis Chain, and feel the plan and ask were both reasonable in this case. However, we would prefer to see a more systematic and conscientious approach to supporting Ethereum, in place of merely approving ad hoc proposals whenever they arise.
Proposal: GIP-110
Vote: For
Reasoning: See our supporting comment for details of the benefits we expect this program will bring. We think this will be an excellent driver of activity for Gnosis Pay, and is well worth experimenting with.
Proposal: GIP-112
Vote: For
Reasoning: These infrastructure upgrades to facilitate Gnosis’ Snapshot strategies is critical for maintain governance, so we strongly support this. The urgent need in light of the upcoming deprecation by TheGraph gives clear rationale for the urgent proposal and timescale. We vocally support.
Proposal: GIP-114
Vote: For
Reasoning: Supporting Blockscout as a relatively reasonable cost maintains diversity of explorer services across the Gnosis Chain ecosystem, providing redundancy in case of issues. The product is good, the team is great and it continues to be a valuable piece of infrastructure for the entire ecosystem.